National Electrical Code 110.9 Interrupting Ratings states that:
Equipment intended to interrupt current at fault levels shall have an interrupting rating at nominal circuit voltage at least equal to the current that is available at the line terminals of the equipment.
To comply with this requirement, a short circuit studies is typically performed to determine the available fault current for comparison to the protective devices interrupting rating. The results of a short circuit study are also a critical component for other studies such as an arc flash study. Requesting the available short-circuit data from the electric utility company should be one of the first tasks in performing the study. This information is very important because it defines the magnitude of current that could flow from the utility and is used as a starting point for arc flash calculations.
In addition to requesting this data for normal operating conditions, for an arc flash study the request should also include minimum short-circuit current conditions, if available. The minimum condition could be for a utility transformer or transmission line out of service or similar scenario. The minimum value can then be used to determine if the lower current could result in a protective device operating more slowly, which may increase the total incident energy during an arc flash.
Having been in charge of the Short Circuit Studies group for a very large electric utility company in a past life, the accuracy of the results depends on the accuracy of the data and, the system configuration at the time (which can seem like a moving target). The available short circuit current can change over time as well. New substations, transmission and distribution lines and other system enhancements can serve to increase the short circuit current for a given area so it is important to review this data periodically.
No Standard Format – Now What?
There is no “standard” format for short-circuit data from an electric utility company. Different utilities may provide this data in a variety of different formats. Several of the more common formats include:
Short-circuit amperes (A)
Short-circuit megavolt-amperes (MVA)
Per-unit and symmetrical components
Of course, with multiple formats, confusion could (and often does) result. I will compare the different formats using a three-phase short-circuit current of 6,000A at the 23-kilovolt (kV) level. Since arc flash calculations are based on a three-phase model, only the three-phase short-circuit calculations are used. Some of the values are slightly rounded.
Short-circuit ampere format
This is the simplest format because it defines the short-circuit current in terms of amperes at a specified location. As an example, the utility has provided the following information:
Short-circuit amperes three-phase = 6,000A
Voltage = 23 kV line-to-line
Since the data is already in terms of amperes, no additional calculations are necessary.
Short-circuit MVA format
Many electric utility companies often provide short- circuit data in terms of short-circuit MVA. This format combines the short-circuit current with the voltage and the square root of 3 (for a three-phase representation) to provide the data in terms of short-circuit power. Below is an example of the MVA format.
MVA = 240 MVA
Voltage = 23 kV line-to-line
To convert three-phase short-circuit MVA to short-circuit current in amperes, use the following equations:
Short-circuit amperes = [MVA x 1,000] / [kV line-to-line x the square root of 3]
where 1,000 is the conversion from MVA to kVA
Short-circuit amperes = [240 MVA x 1,000] / [23 kV line-to-line x 1.732]
Short-circuit amperes = 6,000A
Per-unit and symmetrical components format
The per-unit and symmetrical component format can appear to be the most complex of all. The term “per-unit” is simply the decimal equivalent of percent, i.e., 50 percent is equal to 0.5 per unit. In general, the per-unit method takes every electrical quantity and scales it by a reference value known as a base quantity. The utility derives the base values from two numbers: the
MVA base and kV base.
Symmetrical components is a method used for solving complex unbalanced power system problems. Such terms as positive, zero and negative sequence are part of the vocabulary of this method, and although the actual theory can be quite complex, calculating the short-circuit current using this approach is not that difficult.
The example below illustrates short-circuit data using the per-unit system and symmetrical components:
MVA base = 100 MVA
kV base = 23 kV line-to-line
Z1 = 0.418 p.u.
Z1 is referred to as the positive sequence impedance and represents the equivalent impedance of the utility in this case. One hundred MVA and 23 kV are the base power and voltage used to determine the “base values” necessary for the calculations.
For the three-phase short-circuit current, only three steps are needed to convert the per-unit and symmetrical component values to short-circuit current in amperes:
I base= [MVA base 1,000] / [kV base x the square root of 3]
= [100 MVA x 1,000] / [ 23kV x the square root of 3]
Step 2: Calculate the per-unit three-phase short-circuit current (I p.u.) with the following equation:
I p.u. = V p.u. / Z1
V p.u. in the equation above is the per-unit voltage. In the absence of being provided the per-unit voltage, which is usually the case, it is common to assume it is 1.0 p.u. This means the actual voltage is 100 percent of the base voltage, so for this example:
V p.u. = 1.0
I p.u. = 1.0 / 0.418 = 2.39 p.u.
Step 3: Convert per-unit short-circuit current to amperes with the following equation:
I amperes= I p.u. I base
= 2.39 p.u. 2,510A
Different methods = same results
Although the three methods seem quite different from each other and some are more complicated, they all produce the same result, which can be used as the starting point for arc flash calculations.
For more about how to perform short circuit calculations, check out our 4 DVD set:
You can also check out (and subscribe to) our YouTube channel for more video instruction about per unit and symmetrical components.
About Jim Phillips: Electrical Power and Arc Flash Training Programs – For over 30 years, Jim Phillips has been helping tens of thousands of people around the world, understand electrical power system design, analysis, arc flash and electrical safety.
Jim is Vice Chair of IEEE 1584, International Chairman of IEC TC78 Live Working and Steering Committee Member – IEEE/NFPA Arc Flash Collaborative Research Project. He has developed a reputation for being one of the best trainers in the electric power industry. Learn More
Arc Flash & Electrical Power Training Classes by Jim Phillips Click Here
Arc Flash & Electrical Power Training Products by Jim Phillips Click Here