Labelling Specification & ScheduleI didn't want to, but have to weigh in on this. In my audit work labeling is all over the map, inconsistent specification, colors, information presented, location, incorrect mitigation labels (e.g. arc flash relay, arc reduction maintenance switch, etc..). Here are a few comments, some you may not like as it will make work for you, but your Electrical Safety Program should cover this off:
1. You shouldn't include HRC for specifying your arc rated clothing on a detailed label when you have completed incident energy analysis. You can only call arc rated clothing by an HRC if you use the Table Method of arc flash hazard analysis.
2. I recommend you stick to ANSI Z535 Standard for the layout of the label and safety colors used, using and applying a consensus based Standard is your best due diliegence in court, using other colors, like blue, pink, green (there is another thread where someone was asked to do this). The colors have meaning and "we" recognize them, "what does pink mean?"
3. I recommend that you "plan" what you do by creating a Arc Flash & Shock Warning label and Signs (for the outside of the doors into your MCC/Electrical Rooms) Labelling Specification & Schedule (table used to document what labels were installed, where and by who). In this specificaiton you stipulate what your simple and detailed label formats are, when you will use Danger (e.g. 40, 50, 60 cal/cm2 if you didn't know the software just defaults to 40 cal/cm2, and you can configure this to tell it when you want Danger).
4. Again on the "plan" theme (e.g. based on ANSI Z10, Plan, Do, Check, Act philsophy) I have attached an MCC elevation drawing that ensures that the label will be installed in the same locations no matter what enterprise wide facility you have them installed in. You a specification and elevation, orthographic drawing to illustrate where you want the labels installed. [I tried to upload pdf, 48kb limit the file was 65kb, if you want the drawing email me at
terry.becker@espsi.ca].
5. You will see some new direction on labels in next 70E, I am at the Technical Committee meetings in Memphis, TN right now. This also emphasizes that you utlimately need a label management system identified in your Electrical Safety Program.
Enough typing on this one.
Terry Becker, P.Eng.
ESPS Electrical Safety Program Solutions INC.
terry.becker@espsi.ca
403-465-3777