Preben Jakobsen wrote:
Dear Arc Flash experts.
In IEEE1584 calculations of "reduced arcing fault current" is based on protective device type 1-14 if U<1kV.
-If type 0 is selected the arcing fault current is reduced to 85%
-If type 1-8 is selected the reduced arcing fault current is "not required" ( not reduced/100%)
- Type 9-14 is MCCB and outside my question
Protective device 1-4 is class RK1 fuses and 5-8 is class L fuses in size from 100 to 2000A.
How do i select protective device type if i use gG fuses according to IEC60269?
Best regards
Preben Jakobsen
Denmark
In addition to Jim's comments I think you answered your own question. Device-specific equations were developed by a single manufacturer (Mersen) for two fuse classes. You can't use it for a different fuse or class because it hasn't been tested for that and a purist would argue that you can't even use fuses from a different manufacturer since there is no data to support whether or not fuses from competitors would give the same performance although pragmatically fuse accuracy is "loose" enough that an argument can be made that it probably wouldn't matter. These equations give MUCH lower incident energy values compared to say the empirical equation because it takes into account current limiting and dynamic resistance of the actual devices.